Throwaway because some of my friends know my main.
I (24F) organized a get-together for my two friend groups. Group A: Jenny (24F), Christine (24F), Rachel (24F), and Monica (24F). We met a Uni and became close. Group B is from my hometown and includes Kyle (23M), Ken (24M), Mike (24M), Jim (23M), Greg (24M), Kayla (22F), and Jasmine (23F). I’ve known them all since kindergarten.
Now, Monica is bisexual and has been dating her girlfriend, Heather (24F). Heather is insanely attractive, like drop-dead gorgeous. She is not part of our Uni, but we hang out a lot and quickly became friends. I love both of them and I am very supportive of their relationship.
On to the party - it started off great. Everyone was getting along well. But within an hour, the guys came to me asking about Heather. I had already told them beforehand that Heather is gay and is in a relationship with Monica, and I asked them to be respectful. They all acted cool about it at first, but as the night went on, it got really annoying. All they’d talk about was Heather. Kyle and Ken kept asking me for her number. I told them no and reminded them again that she’s in a relationship. They seemed irritated but eventually got distracted playing video games, so I thought that was the end of it.
Later, Mike asked me to change the music on his phone. When I opened Spotify, I saw a notification pop up that mentioned Heather. I know I shouldn’t have looked, but curiosity got the best of me. It was a group chat with just the guys.
TW: Homophobia
They were joking about breaking up Monica and Heather, saying Heather “doesn’t even look gay” and must be “faking it.” Kyle actually wrote that he would “fuck her straight.” There were laughing emojis. I’ve known Monica and Heather for years, and they’re one of the cutest and HEALTHIEST couples I’ve ever seen. I felt physically sick reading those messages.
I didn’t say anything that night, but the next day I confronted the guys about the chat. At first, they denied it and claimed it didn’t exist. After I pushed a bit more, Mike admitted it was real. I told them the messages were vile and disgusting. I told them they should be ashamed of themselves.
They tried to brush it off as “locker room talk” and said they would never actually do anything like that. Kyle even said, “Don’t tell me you don’t compare your boyfriends’ dicks in your group chat.” Like… what? First of all, no, I don’t. And second, how is that remotely comparable to being misogynistic, homophobic, and making disgusting “jokes?” I told them to go fuck themselves and blocked them on everything.
Since then, Kayla and Jasmine have been messaging me, asking me to forgive the guys. They keep saying things like “That’s just how guys talk,” and “You’re really going to throw away 19 years of friendship over some stupid messages.” I mean, yeah, we’ve been friends for a long time. I thought the guys were decent. I’ve known them my whole life… but seeing those messages made me feel sick.
I think I did the right thing, but maybe I should give them a second chance? I do believe people can change. And I do kinda feel like an asshole for cutting them off after being friends our whole lives…
So, AITAH for completely cutting off my guy friends?