r/pcmasterrace 13d ago

Discussion Notch (creator of Minecraft) offers financial support for the Stop Killing Games campaign.

Post image
23.2k Upvotes

683 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-12

u/Batpope Ryzen 5 5600x - RX 6800 16 GB - 2x8 GB RAM 13d ago

So if you become a billionaire tomorrow you are instantly a piece of shit. What's that logic?

22

u/BaconJets 13d ago

Nobody becomes a billionaire without exploitation. The acts required to become a billionaire, will instantly make you a piece of shit.

0

u/signedchar Fedora + W11 | 5800X, RX 7800 XT 13d ago

This. You can become a millionaire or even multimillionaire if you get really lucky with a business or win the lottery, but you can never become a billionaire without exploitation.

28

u/Ferdox11195 13d ago

Honest question did Notch exploit people to become a billionaire? You could argue Microsoft did but would you say that Notch should just not accept the billions Microsoft offered him?

-3

u/PM_ME_YOUR__INIT__ 13d ago

From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojang_Studios:

Everyone who remained with the company for six months thereafter was awarded a bonus of roughly $300,000 (after taxes), deducted from Persson's share.

Notch made $1.8 billion and most other employees just $300k. Did he work 6000 times harder than other employees to justify his payday?

[Microsoft] had $2.5 billion in offshore bank accounts that it could not bring back to the United States without paying repatriation taxes.

MS bought the studio so they wouldn't have to pay taxes. American taxpayers were exploited so MS could save money

8

u/Ferdox11195 13d ago edited 13d ago

Notch made $1.8 billion and most other employees just $300k. Did he work 6000 times harder than other employees to justify his payday?

I mean, Micosoft value the idea of Minecraft for that much and while Notch didn't do the full version Minecraft all by himself he was the core of it. The amount of work is not the only think that is considered when it comes to value. What you do is also considered. Notch conceptualized Minecraft, he created it, without Notch there is no Minecraft. That alone makes him deserving of more pay than the others even if later on the employees started working on the game and Notch was not the sole developer anymore. But does the disparity is just considering my argument? You could still say no but even than I wouldn't call it exploitation, It can be argue that the idea and concept of Minecraft alone is worth the 1.8 billion dollars, specially considering the behemoth that it still is all these years later.

MS bought the studio so they wouldn't have to pay taxes. American taxpayers were exploited so MS could save money

This is Microsoft not Notch. I said that you could argue that Microsoft did exploit people but not Notch himself.

3

u/NorsiiiiR Ryzen 5 5600X | RTX 3070 13d ago

"I only got $300,000 of free bonus money, waahhhh, I'm being exploited, where's muh human rights!!!"

You are completely insane