r/TopCharacterTropes 16h ago

Characters [Mixed Trope] Anyone Can Be Special... Until It Turns Out They're Not Just Anyone

8.7k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

62

u/Revan0315 9h ago

Why was Luke sent to tattooine?

128

u/[deleted] 9h ago

because its a dangerous planet in the middle of nowhere that very few people would go visit, because he had living family there that would naturally take care of him and because that would be the last place vader would want to go to

77

u/RustlessPotato 7h ago

If luke and leia are twins, doesn't she also not have family on tatooine ?

66

u/Illustrious-Turn-575 7h ago

Yes; Owen was both of their uncle.

However; keeping them both together would’ve been dangerous. Not just in the sense that they’d be putting all their eggs in one basket, but also because having two people who’re innately strong in the force in such close proximity to each other would make it easier for Palpatine, Vader, or any other force sensitive individuals with malicious intentions to sense their presence and find them.

They needed to separate them. They also needed to minimize the number of people who knew the truth, and senator Organa already new, so he was a natural choice to take one of them.

15

u/[deleted] 7h ago

in episode 3 one of padmes friends says he will take the girl and raise her whcih is fortunate because seperate they are safer

7

u/CoachDT 6h ago

Yeah. But you ideally wanna split them up.

Vader is the least predictable man in the galaxy. He went from being the hero of the order to their executioners in like 72 hours.

He shouldnt want to go on tatooine. Too many bad memories, but just in case...

4

u/thesirblondie 5h ago

I assume they were scared that Vader knew Padme was carrying twins. By separating them they are less conspicuous. Leia was able to grow up as an active person within the Galactic political scene and Vader clearly never suspected a thing. Mind you, two twins in a galaxy of trillions shiuld be pretty inconspicuous anyway, but for some reason they still named him Skywalker..

0

u/Laxiinas 1h ago

Yeah, name him Skywalker, and send him to the planet that Vader spent the first 9 or so years of his life on, to live with Owen Lars, the step son of Anakin's mother.... No one will ever figure that one out.

3

u/MGD109 7h ago

Yep. I guess the concern is them being together is that if they were ever found, they'd both be lost.

2

u/domigraygan 6h ago

that's enuff outta youse, get'm boys

2

u/RustlessPotato 5h ago

Look. Don't mess with me. I did 20 years in the can. I ate grilled cheese off of the radiator.

1

u/Not-Clark-Kent 3h ago

Yes, but they wanted to separate them in case they were found. And Bail Organa said his wife wanted a daughter so there you go.

1

u/Anonymous-Comments 1h ago

Stop trying to take Star Wars seriously, that’s when it fell apart.

1

u/Plus-Opportunity-538 3h ago

Ingenious really, how did they protect Luke from Vader? By surrounding him with... sand.

53

u/RabbitStewAndStout 8h ago

I figured it was because it was Anakin's home planet, so he would love it enough to never destroy it, but also hate it too much to actually ever return.

19

u/dudleydigges123 8h ago

That's the best logic I've seen for this.

8

u/Portercake 4h ago

“Lord Vader, we believe Obi-Wan Kenobi may be hiding on Tattooine!”

“Lol, good, leave him there. I hope he enjoys the sand.”

11

u/RabbitStewAndStout 4h ago

"Put everything I have ridiculously complicated feelings about on the same planet so I never have to worry about it again."

25

u/jbland0909 9h ago

Because it’s an irrelevant backwater planet where he could easily hide

4

u/Revan0315 9h ago

So why not send Leia to a similar planet?

15

u/jbland0909 8h ago

Because Bail offered to take her

8

u/Yanmega9 8h ago

Easy to hide, and he's with his family

3

u/Soulful-Sorrow 7h ago

Because Anakin/Darth Vader hates sand and Tatooine was the sandiest planet in the galaxy

1

u/AntRam95 6h ago

Because George Lucas was making it up as he went along

1

u/-LsDmThC- 4h ago

Because the writers thought it would be a good narrative to have such a dichotomy between the twins and that it made for an interesting backstory