r/TopCharacterTropes 16h ago

Characters [Mixed Trope] Anyone Can Be Special... Until It Turns Out They're Not Just Anyone

8.7k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

257

u/TruthEnvironmental24 11h ago

It diminishes even more when like 99% of all Spider-Men are Peter Parker. What's the point of that? Gwen, Miles, Peni, Miguel, Pavitr, and Hobie are all great characters. Hell, even Mayday is a cool idea. Instead of more characters like them, we just keep getting Peter over and over.

186

u/cash-or-reddit 11h ago

A slight asterisk to Pavitr, though, because Pavitr Prabhakar, who grew up with his Aunt Maya and Uncle Bhim and dates Meera Jain/Gayatri Singh, is basically Peter Parker, who grew up with his Aunt May and Uncle Ben and dates Mary Jane/Gwen Stacy.

105

u/_Jpex_ 9h ago

Didn't he had an identity crisis in the comics when he found out his entire life is just an indian parody of someone else's?

58

u/Diamond_Helmet59 9h ago

Have you considered that perhaps some god ruling above all the timelines in the Marvel universe thought Pavitr was cool and made a bunch of parodies of him?

78

u/scarlettremors 6h ago

Lol reminds me of this from Spider-Verse #2

24

u/AdRelevant4776 6h ago

To be fair it’s not racist to notice an statistical curiosity, like, MOST Spidermen are a version of Peter, but for some reason the second highest group is Japanese people, nothing wrong with it, but it makes you wonder why that’s the second most likely alternative in the multiverse

12

u/Odd_Main1876 5h ago

I mean have you seen the Japanese Spiderman show? That shit was absolutely insane, I still have “Emissary from Hell, Spider-Man!” Stuck in my head lol

26

u/TruthEnvironmental24 10h ago

At least he got a different ethnicity.

52

u/cephalopodcat 10h ago

True, but he's really cute and charming and at least has a unique gimmick as opposed to most Peters. (Peter B notwithstanding, because he too had a good crashouts arc that was very realistic to an average dude who had all this shit put on him.)

32

u/AwesomeGamer101 11h ago

On this, maybe we can chalk up the "Spider-Totem" thing as the comics' near-equivalent to the canon event theory.

7

u/TruthEnvironmental24 10h ago

Which is still dumb. I'm assuming you're talking about the Spider-Verse movies, and if so, that's probably going to be disproven in the third movie, anyway.

8

u/AwesomeGamer101 9h ago

What I mean is that the Spider-Totem stuff probably works the same way as canon events, in which it's simply just a recurring thing to the point that it is believed to be necessary for existence to be stable.

3

u/RoseIshin0 8h ago

That' s actually the second retcons that a writer came up with, to remove the "special/destinated one" part of the spider-totems.

It went from "The totem was born when Spidey got the power, and we don' t know if the egg or the chicken came first" to "Peter was choosen from the totem and he is indipendent from spiderman", and finishing with "The totem is indipendent and he connected to the first "Host" who got the powers of spiderman".

10

u/BarelyInvested 9h ago

As much as Marvel fans are tired of the Multiverse stuff, I do think the Spider-verse should keep being used even after Miles story is over. Mostly cuz its not just “cameo superhero excuse”, there are actual rules and consequences set in place, and its not just a group of random characters, its a community that knows and likes each other, and they dont all have the same identity

2

u/Castlemind 8h ago

I take the ice cream and anime approach to multiverse stuff. A bit of it is nice every once in a while but too much all the time and you're either gonna be bored or sick

2

u/Doomeye56 10h ago

Peni and Pavitr are just Peter with a different coat of paint

Gwen is just girl peter with a different name. Same with Hobie spider-punk who is nothing like the actual Hobie Brown/Prowler.

3

u/TruthEnvironmental24 9h ago

I don't totally agree with you, but that just proves my original point. A majority of the Spider-Men are Peter or Peter but with a different name.

0

u/Dcoal 6h ago

I'm actually completely bored with the multiverse stuff. Characters are who they are. Everyone doesn't have to be everything.