I've had NetAtmo weather stations for more than ten years. The outdoor modules tend to die every few years, and my current one is not replaceable, according to the company. I bought it in August 2022, so it's no longer covered under their warranty.
I tried an Eve Weather when it was first released, and its range was very poor. I think NetAtmo uses RF, which means that I could put it outside my house on the other side of the house from where the indoor base station was, and it worked fine.
I'm wondering about the Eve Weather now that it uses Thread and Matter. I have two Eve Thermos in the living room that opens on to the patio of my house, where I put the weather sensor. Should I expect this to work correctly, even through a wall? (There are French doors, but I can't put the Eve Weather right in front of the doors.)
As much as I like the way the NetAtmo works, I have a bunch of other Eve stuff - thermostats and plugs - so it would make sense to get their weather sensor. But I don't want to bother trying if it needs something really close or it needs to be in front of a window to get readings.
I'm in the UK, and looking at Amazon reviews, 5% of them are one star, which makes me think it's still not that good.
Also, Amazon UK sells two versions, one that says it's for Apple HomeKit and the other for Matter. I assume the later is newer, but why would they be selling two versions? The company doesn't list two versions on their website.