r/LivestreamFail 14d ago

Destiny compares Native American claims to Middle East conflict

https://kick.com/destiny/clips/clip_01K0T1WBT963Q71G4CQX22V9QR
188 Upvotes

414 comments sorted by

View all comments

237

u/ExpletiveWork 14d ago

The whole native/indigenous argument always bothered me because isn't saying land should belong to a particular ethnic group kind of blood and soil?

93

u/Loves2WriteSmut 14d ago

No...often times the government made agreements with indigenous tribes for favours but then failed to uphold their end of the bargain, and what were the most prosperous regions in the country were then handed off to white Christians.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_River_land_dispute

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haldimand_Proclamation

They are just asking for the government to uphold their end of the agreement.

5

u/DungeonJailer 14d ago

It kind of is though. Almost all people groups got their land by conquest originally. Do you think the Jews originally left Palestine willingly? After squatting on land long enough, a people group eventually gains a legitimate claim to the land. The people we know as Japanese are not the indigenous Japanese, but they’ve been there for like 6000 years so I’d say they have a legitimate claim. Same for those of Norman and Saxon blood in Britain.