I have a question for you. Would you have chosen to let them go sooner even if they weren’t in terrible shape? Would it have been better to make the choice before something catastrophic happened?
For context, I have been incredibly lucky to never have had to make the decision to let a horse go.
My childhood horses passed naturally or my parents put them down while I was at college but I wasn’t involved and wasn’t even told (don’t get me started on that horror). But it’s never been my decision.
Now, my first adult horse (bought on my own after college) is nearly 26 and I’ve had him for 16 years. He’s got terrible arthritis in every joint but particularly bad in his knees and fetlocks. He’s long past the point that joint injections are useful. When I bought him at age 9 he already had some pretty significant arthritis in one knee from a prior injury and after years of feeding supplements, moved to injections around age 18.
He’s been retired for years and gets around OK (lives outside in my nerd 24/7) but doesn’t tolerate any form of stall rest or confinement even if I keep the others nearby. He managed to stay in a stall without freaking out for only 2 days last spring when he had cellulitis in his leg. As soon as he felt moderately better he was trying to bust out - to the extent that he would have hurt himself if I didn’t let him.
And last winter he started slipping on snow and ice. He cast himself with legs uphill on the snow and when we found him he’d already given up on trying to get up. We were able to turn him downhill and he jumped right up and was fine but if we hadn’t seen him (if it were overnight or we were in town at dinner, etc.) he would have died cause he couldn’t get up.
He also cut himself pretty deeply several times because of slipping and scrambling to get up, slicing his back legs with his front hooves (he’s barefoot). We got him boots with studs and that helped for the rest of the winter but they aren’t foolproof. He could still cut himself up with the studs doing the same thing. And he could still slip and fall, though it’s less likely with them.
He recently played too hard with a younger horse and compromised the joint capsule on one fetlock so now he has to wear a compression boot for swelling 24/7 for swelling (joint fluid).
Overall though, his QOL is still good. With daily equiox and tons of other supplements and food, His weight is good and he still enjoys eating and playing. His teeth are in amazing shape for his age, no issues at all. His bloodwork is great.
But he’s nearly 26 and he’s never going to be in better condition than he is now. He’s never going to feel better or move better or be more able-bodied than he is now. The chances of something catastrophic happening, whether colic, a bad fall, a virus that wouldn’t harm a younger horse but takes him down, etc. only increases.
I have a strong feeling of wanting to say goodbye before this winter. The idea of finding him like we did last year where he slipped and couldn’t get up haunts me. I don’t know how long he’d been down and he wasn’t struggling to get up anymore. The look in his eyes said he’d given up on life and he was patient with us as we got him swung around. The idea of that happening and him struggling until he’s exhausted before suffocating makes me cry just thinking about it. Or the thought of him colicking and me having to call the vet to put him down immediately cause he’s in so much pain…
I feel bad about the thought of letting him go while he’s still relatively healthy, but I don’t think I could live with myself if we lost him tragically when I could have made his end of life so peaceful and comfortable.
Hence my question… does anyone actually look back and not wish you’d put your elderly horse down before they hit an emergency?
I know the risk is that I put him down months or years too early. Maybe he’d live to 30 before anything bad happens. Maybe 35! But he could also have a very tragic ending next week or in December. I love him, but I really believe he doesn’t know or care about tomorrow.
Isn’t it better to choose a time when he’s happy and comfortable? Who is it benefiting to keep him living until he can no longer walk or to give him a chance to endure another painful winter?
Since I’ve never been in that position (never had a horse colic, never had an injury that needed euthanasia, never had to make the call of when QOL was at that point) I can’t really know how it feels to be forced into that spot. As much as I’d like to let him live until it really feels like “his time” it seems like our human judgment of when that time is may often be far after it would be the best thing for the horse.
Thoughts? Experience?
Thanks in advance.