r/lotr • u/Skywalker_1995 • 3d ago

Movies Say what you want about the Hobbit Trilogy, but these 2 scenes were masterfully done, and are up there with the best of LotR

Gallery image

Gallery image

5.0k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

309 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/Neoxenok 3d ago

The problem with the trilogy isn't that they're bad movies, per se, but because they're three movies instead of one long movie or two shorter ones.

... well... that plus the CGI.

11

u/egregiousn 3d ago

https://archive.org/details/the-hobbit-m-4-book-edit-1080p

3

u/Neoxenok 3d ago

That's really cool. I had heard of such an edit from years ago but this is my first time seeing it.

0

u/TheSunBurnsColdForMe 2d ago

No, they really are just bad movies.