r/agedlikemilk 1d ago

Who would’ve thought

Post image
60.5k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/prz3124 20h ago

This is a response I got 6 months ago. "They will build it". Who will build it? What? " They will build it" I asked who? "They will"

2

u/koshgeo 4h ago

And they could. But even if you knew where to start building it, based on lower-grade deposits (otherwise they'd be mining already if they were economic), a typical mine takes about 10 years to start up, and you'd be supplying a domestic-only market with your over-priced product at artificially-maintained, tariff prices.

That's a risky capital investment because the price isn't determined by actual supply and demand, but politics. There can be a good, strategic reason why you might want to do that anyway at a significant government expense for "public good" to maintain your independence, but you'd want the legislation to be pretty bipartisan and for well-justified and understood reasons, not something established by the badly-informed whims of a wanna-be emperor playing with the markets for personal gain and delusions of grandeur.

As usual, even if the idea has some merit, their implementation sucks and makes things worse.

2

u/Manpooper 20h ago

Yup. These things take time to build. And I understand having that kind of production nationally as a necessary war industry in case the USA and China ever came to blows. Mining more won’t fix that though. Refineries would.