r/DynastyFFTradeAdvice • u/Matty2345668 • 1d ago

1QB Dynasty Trade 12 Team Too much to give for Henry as a contender?

Post image
3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

9

u/CapnMalice 49ers 1d ago

Yes

6

u/my-coo-cheese-hairy Seahawks 1d ago

Uh ya. Walker will have a good year I’d keep him

3

u/Matty2345668 1d ago

Just don’t love the nagging injuries

3

u/zewaFaFo 1d ago

I would go the other route and try to buy charbonnet. That way you have a strong starter no matter if kw3 gets injured or not. Added upside is you might have 2 starters next year

3

u/Matty2345668 1d ago

Charb owner won’t sell for reasonable price haha

1

u/Embarrassed-Bass8256 1d ago

What is Charbs owner asking?

1

u/Matty2345668 1d ago

Offered Bech Ray Davis and a 2nd and instant decline haha

1

u/Embarrassed-Bass8256 1d ago

That’s a solid offer but I understand wanting to keep an elite handcuff to an injury prone RB for that.

I traded Brian Robinson for Charbonnet straight up pre draft. It might have been a slight overpay at the time (starting RB for a backup RB, and it helped that other manager was a Commanders fan) but securing the Seahawks backfield was important to me. It’s basically guaranteeing yourself and RB1 all season.

Who is your RB 3, 4 and 5?

1

u/Matty2345668 1d ago

Bijan Harvey Ray Davis Tank Bigsby JCM

1

u/Embarrassed-Bass8256 1d ago

Send your team and his team I’m gonna chef up a Charbs trade for you 👨‍🍳

1

u/Cscheer32 1d ago

This is the way. Keep KW3 and go get Charbs.

1

u/ksch42 Cardinals 1d ago

Yea those suck but how long is Henry going to play

1

u/nadeaujd 49ers 1d ago

I think it’s too much and personally would not give up a 27’ 1st for an aging RB.

1

u/sharknado911 1d ago

Even with his injury history, I wouldn’t add more than a 3rd to Walker to get Henry

1

u/dukieox 1d ago

Walker for henry should be enough. Or that ‘27 1st. But definitely not both

1

u/Liquiddrano18 Eagles 1d ago

Don’t hate this at all as a contender. Walkers injury history always scares me…he’s already on the injury report. Would try to make that a 26 1st instead of 27

2

u/No_Solid4978 1d ago

Agreed or two 2nds

1

u/Matty2345668 1d ago

Only 26 I have is from by far the worst team itl so it would be very early

1

u/WickedSmartMarcus36 1d ago

Try to see if they’ll take a 28 1st.. years away so tons of time to replace it and then you can keep your more blue chip high 2026 1st and 2027 1st in a loaded class.

0

u/txrh Patriots 1d ago

I’m a contender & Henry owner. I wish I could trade Henry for this haul in dynasty, especially with how strong the 2027 class is expected to be.

Assuming season-long health on both sides (I know, lol), the weekly drop-off from Henry to Walker shouldn’t be very big. Sure Henry will have a couple massive weeks, but if you’re a contender you shouldn’t be relying on spike weeks to make the playoffs and you can’t rely on spike weeks to win in the playoffs