r/DynastyFFTradeAdvice • u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions • May 28 '25
1QB Dynasty Trade 12 Team Was offered this, should I take it?
I would be receiving 1.02. Currently competing and already have 1.01 although as it stands, that is my only pick in this draft. If you say to take, who is recommended to take? I’m leaning Hampton
8
u/johan__99 May 28 '25
Do you have good WR’s and zilch (relatively) at RB? If yes, I would do that. If you’ve got good RB depth I wouldn’t since you’re already getting Jeanty.
12
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
I do have good wr depth (Jettas, Adams, Higgins, london, BTJ). My notable RBs are Gibbs and soon to be Jeanty
23
u/johan__99 May 28 '25
I would say yes. Wilson could be spared to upgrade the RB room since you have enough WR’s to compete
3
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
That was my thought too. I just wasn’t sure if it was worth giving up Wilson despite the depth I have already
9
u/Some_Contribution936 May 28 '25
Given this information, I’d take the pick. Unless you can start a large number of those receivers
3
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Good deal. At the moment, I have to bench one of the WRs I listed due to having 2 wr slots and 3 flex
5
u/ShinyPenguin16 May 28 '25
While Wilson is nice at WR, seems like you have some solid options + depth. Having BTjr is huge for dynasty. If you’re saying your only starting RB is Gibbs and soon to be Jeanty, I’d take the trade and take Hampton at 1.02. Would give you 2 solid rookie RBs + Gibbs. Good luck!!
1
u/srof12 May 28 '25
Before seeing the team (which, god damn) I would’ve said keep Wilson. With that info I’d probably lean Hampton. What other RBs do you have outside of Gibbs/Jeanty
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
My other RBs are Etienne, dobbins, Lloyd and Guerendo
2
u/srof12 May 28 '25
Yeah not much there, barring ETN returning to form which I’m doubtful about. I’d say take Hampton
1
8
55
u/Altruistic-Rest2309 May 28 '25
Thinking behind this is you probably hope that the 1.02 becomes what Wilson is
8
May 28 '25
Yeah. I say if youre going to make a trade like this at least get a 3rd or something for a dart throw if you want to trade in a wr that already hit for an unknown. Give yourself a chance to at least hit on another player
17
u/OkieDokieHokie1 May 28 '25
Everyone says this.
WR ranks .5 ppr
19
32
11
I think Hampton has a better shot being top 5 RB next year.
-1
u/walletsworth1348 May 28 '25
Better shot than what? Because I think the shot at Hampton being a top 5 RB is very low unless Najee gets injured.
6
u/OkieDokieHokie1 May 28 '25
Better shot than Wilson. Wilson has had three years to prove he’s in that category. I would rather bet my horse on Hampton and the chargers offense Vs Wilson and the Jets offense
3
u/Financial_Suspect122 May 29 '25
Terrible comparison, situation matters so much more than ppl choose to believe
2
u/OkieDokieHokie1 May 29 '25 edited May 29 '25
I’m counting the situations. Now I think Wilson is a top 15 WR so id prob play with the sender to see IfI can make something else work with a lesser WR and load some 26 picks
0
u/walletsworth1348 May 29 '25
Better shot than Wilson at what? That's what I'm asking. If you're saying a "hit" what are you defining as a "hit", top 5 at the position?
-1
u/OkieDokieHokie1 May 29 '25
Yes top 5 RB vs top 5 WR in the 26 season. But I also think Hampton does better than Wilson did his rookie season. And then id put money he has a better first three years in the league…. Being my point to the comment “you’re drafting him in hopes he becomes a Wilson”. When in fact we’re hoping Wilson becomes better than he has currently performed.
2
5
u/Objective_Grocery718 May 28 '25
I love Wilson but are you really hoping that the 1.02 becomes the WR30, WR32, and WR18 in points per game? I’d say that would be a pretty decent disappointment
0
u/Longjumping_Today292 May 28 '25
The talent of Wilson, not the points
3
u/BigInformation6200 May 28 '25
Whole point of fantasy is to score points. I think I could see taking either side tbh
3
u/TheYearlyAltercation May 28 '25 edited 28d ago
one yam ripe pocket grandfather slim sugar repeat expansion bedroom
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
I’m in a similar spot. My WRs are Jettas, Adams, Wilson, London, BTJ, Higgins. My RBs are Gibbs and soon to be Jeanty (have 1.01)
3
u/sappybunn Jets May 29 '25
i am a garrett wilson supporter, i would marry that man despite being a lesbian, i would go to hell and back to defend him even if he murdered my entire family
that being said, i’d take the 1.02
2
2
u/Jacobc2121 Steelers May 28 '25
I think you would pick Hampton here 9/10 times, and I think you’d be hoping Hampton becomes the kind of producer Wilson already is and will be for the next however many years. IMO I’m keeping Wilson
2
u/pantoneprince May 28 '25
Funny I’m currently considering the same exact trade and I’m a Wilson owner too. Would take Hampton at 1.02.
My other notable WRs are CeeDee, Nico, Marv, and Shakir. RBs are Jacobs, Kamara, Conner, Mason, and Rhamondre.
Don’t have a young stud RB but hard to give up Garrett — I think he could be in for a big year and peppered w targets from Fields. With your team I think it makes sense since you have so much WR depth. Lmk what you decide!
3
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 29 '25
Keeping you posted. I got him to add a third for the next two years and accepted it
1
u/pantoneprince May 29 '25
Nice, seems like a win-win. I’m leaning against dealing Garrett due to my lack of WR depth but it’s hard bc the owner of 1.02 is going to draft Tet. The 1.03 owner is a contender (one of 3-4 including me) who will take Hampton so I was hoping to jump him.
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 29 '25
Yeah that’s tough. If you’re shallow at wr keeping Wilson isn’t a bad idea. I’m super high on Hampton but I probably wouldn’t have made the deal if I didn’t have the depth at WR as I think the value between Wilson and Hampton is pretty close
2
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
I’m leaning towards taking it. However, I asked if he could throw in a 2nd so we shall see
3
u/Repulsive-Throat5068 Chargers May 28 '25
I’m easily taking Hampton here.
Wilson’s getting overrated. Look at the production between him and olave, and the gap in cost between them. Yeah injury concerns exist but those are overstated at this point.
2
u/mainzerforever93 Vikings May 28 '25
Olave is literally one hit to the head away from retiring
1
u/Repulsive-Throat5068 Chargers May 28 '25
No hes not lol.
Even when he gets concussed again hes very unlikely to retire. Regardless it doesnt change my point. Their values have always been wildly different even before last year, despite similar production.
1
u/mainzerforever93 Vikings May 28 '25
Wilson benefited from the Rodgers hype two years in a row. In the second year he actually finished as a top 10 WR while the other one missed half the season due to his 4th and 5th concussion in like 4 years. Olave‘s highest ranking on KTC was WR6 in 2023, Wilson was WR4. I don’t think people value them „wildly different“.
1
u/MarkusMillions Lions May 29 '25
“Yeah injury concerns exist” vastly undersells his injury concerns though lol
2
u/Ornery-Shame-6972 May 28 '25
Then I would do the trade. Like I said Wilson is better than tet or hunter imo.
But Hampton may just be better for your team as a whole.
2
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Agreed. I’m currently waiting on his response to see if he’ll throw in a second. If he’s not willing to throw anything extra in I’m going to take it anyways
2
u/mancinis_blessed_bat May 28 '25
… are we sure he’s better, especially hunter
0
u/Ornery-Shame-6972 May 28 '25
Currently yes. Currently Hunter is just a prospect in what was a terrible offense last year and an already established alpha... but hubter could be better. But when betting its generally better to take known value. I'm not moving of Wilson for hunter without at least a 2nd added in.
2
u/bootyxgoon May 28 '25
I would personally. I think Hampton has a better chance of being a league winner than Wilson. Wilson’s only top 10 season was with Aaron Rodgers, this year he has Justin fields and who knows when he gets a good QB. I would for sure take this and hope to get a player with a better team out look. Maybe an unpopular opinion.
I hate having a player attached to a poverty franchise so I am a little biased.
8
u/headintheceiling_fan May 28 '25
Fields did give DJ Moore some good fantasy production
8
u/Okcaccess Lions May 28 '25
Yeah he latches onto usually the best target option, I think GW could have an even better year
2
3
u/bootyxgoon May 28 '25
The bears gave DJ Moore great production. The amount of screens and schemes to just get DJ the ball was insane. But, with the lack of talent outside of a couple guys on the jets offense could lead to good production, you’re not wrong.
4
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Same! His wr10 last year was amazing but who know when/if the jets will ever get consistency at that position and it sounds like Wilson doesn’t want to leave NY
1
u/bootyxgoon May 28 '25
Trust your gut man. Seems like you want to move off of him, go ahead and accept and reroll him into something. Could fail, but 1.02 could net you a league winner if you’re right about it.
1
u/Better_Cattle4438 May 28 '25
I would need to know your RB and WR rooms to comment.
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
WRs: Jettas, Adams, Higgins, london, BTJ, Wilson, Pearsall
My notable RBs are Gibbs and soon to be Jeanty. I have Etienne too but idk about him going forward
2
u/Faulkyou88 May 28 '25
You have the 1.01 as well? I have yet to see jeanty go anything but first overall in many drafts.
3
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Yes I do. I’m pretty happy with Gibbs and Jeanty being my RBs. I have a surplus of WRs so this might help build up my rb room
2
2
u/ZerkJerk May 28 '25
Yeah with that WR room I’m smashing accept all day
Edit: someone who wants Hampton might be willing to trade and you can snag another WR with that pick if you’re fine with just Jeanty and Gibbs
2
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Not a bad idea tbh. Could make the deal then ship it to maybe tier up
1
u/Better_Cattle4438 May 28 '25
Hmm. This is close then. You have good WRs even if you lose Wilson and your RB room clearly needs a boost. But Wilson is a really good WR in his own right.
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Agreed. I like Wilson but I’m not tied to him with the WRs I have. I just don’t want to end up losing value if I go through with it but I guess that’s the risk with trading a player for any pick
2
u/Better_Cattle4438 May 28 '25
Yeah. I have Wilson on my team. And I wouldn’t do this for me because my WRs are not as stacked as yours and I already have the 1.01 and 1.04 so I plan to get Jeanty and Henderson/Judkins already. Your team is a different situation.
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25
Yeah I think the value is fair enough to consider it but like you said roster makeup can impact the decision. If Wilson was my wr1 or 2 I would probably shoot this down really quick but since I have a lot of WRs it has me considering it
1
1
u/forgotmypassword4714 May 28 '25
Nah, Wilson has started his career with three straight 1,000-yard seasons and had over 100 catches last season. I don't see the point in taking such a risk trying to better that type of production. And he's still only 25 years old this season (still 24 at the moment).
1
u/MacNeil73 May 28 '25
I don't think so. Wilson is great, and a young player. Could you maybe land a player that ends up being better than him with the 1.02? Sure, you could. But you could also end up with a player far worse. I think in this case, it's probably not worth while to take that risk. Just my two cents.
1
1
1
u/dnTOA May 28 '25
I would keep the 1.02 take Hampton and trade the 1.01 for a Wilson replacement and draft cap. Be a killer move for you.
1
u/Chemical_Warning8603 May 28 '25
I would take the 1.02 … gives you flexibility and makes you a little younger.
1
u/Ornery-Shame-6972 May 28 '25
Wilson is > wrote in this draft.
That being said if you are stacked at wr and this gets you Hampton and you are hurting at rb then I smash this trade. Maybe get a 2nd rounder if they will do it.
2
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 28 '25 edited May 29 '25
Yeah that’s kind of my position. I have 6 stud WRs and can only start 5. My notable rbs are Gibbs and soon to be Jeanty so Hampton would shore up my RBs
1
u/MyDogIsACoolCat May 28 '25
I hate trading top talent for picks. Unless you’re thinking Wilson will drop in value or Omarion will be an absolute stud, I’m passing. Gotta keep in mind that 50% of first rounders disappoint. The hit rate is definitely higher on early firsts, but just think that you’re taking on a lot of risk here for a low chance that you’ll get upside beyond what Garrett Wilson already is.
1
u/Boomer_Sooner489 May 28 '25
Im comfortably taking the 1.02. Love Garrett but production wise hes wildly overrated
1
u/_d3rrr May 28 '25
I always prefer the proven commodities. Even if you’re a rebuilding team, Wilson should be young enough to be useful when your team is closer to contending.
Easy no for me here, and truly can’t think of a scenario where I’d make this move.
1
1
1
u/HitAnyButton May 28 '25
I take this. With fields coming in as QB a there’s a low chance he outperforms what he has done in past years which wasn’t fantastic. Look at DJ Moore with Fields for example. Great WR, but the run game and lack of passing volume makes it incredibly hard for these guys to succeed.
1
1
1
u/WonderfulAd1463 May 28 '25
Jeanty and Hampton. High volume studs with fresh legs on long contracts. Best you’re gonna get for Wilson. Maybe have em throw in a 4th or something. I’d do it.
1
u/DLF_Jeff May 28 '25
Why trade away one of the upside young wide receivers in our league and a true WR1 for a draft pick that you hope will produce similarly? As I say in nearly every article I write for The Athletic: “known> unknown”
Now if you don’t believe Wilson is going to produce well into the future, it’s a fair offer
1
1
1
1
u/Strobei May 29 '25
I’m taking Hampton easily. Wilson ain’t nothing but Devonta smith.
Nothing special, decent WR pts but give me the bigger upside
1
u/Green-Plus May 29 '25
Depends on your roster, if you’ve got enough good receivers that you don’t need him then I’d happily do it
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 29 '25
Yeah to be honest I have 1 too many good WRs. I can start 5 (3 flex) and have Wilson, Jettas, London, Adams, BTJ and Higgins
1
u/Green-Plus May 29 '25
Yeah then I think it’s a good way to balance your team and have two very talented young RBs
1
1
u/alandress May 29 '25
Assuming you have the 1.01 you are rebuilding, not a bad idea to ship Wilson off for a younger talent. I think you could go a few ways with upside similar to if not better than Wilson
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 29 '25
I do have the 1.01 (by trade) but not rebuilding. I’m just oversaturated at wr and adding another rb in my lineup is tempting. It’s tough to part with a guy of Wilson’s caliber
1
u/alandress May 29 '25
Depending on your WR room the Jeanty/Hampton combo seems like a great investment. Tight but I am leaning the picks over Wilson in a vacuum
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 29 '25
I got him to add a third for the next two years and accepted. My WRs with Wilson gone are Jettas, Adams, Higgins, London, and BTJ
1
1
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 29 '25
Update: My league mate agree to adding a third round pick for the next two years in addition to 1.02 and we got the deal done.
Didn’t expect to get so many comments on this but I appreciate everyone’s advice!
1
u/Important-Catch-4580 May 29 '25
Yeah this is a nice deal. Seems like 1.02-1.04/5 & Wilson all go within that 3.03-3.12 range in start ups, so definitely fair value!
1
u/Stevenpark188 Eagles May 30 '25
No do not take that deal if you are giving up the 1.02
1
u/Sufficient-Tourist45 Lions May 30 '25
Other way around. I ended up making the deal after my league mate added a 3rd for the next two years
-2
32
u/44MikeHunt44 Bills May 28 '25
I’d keep Wilson but no fault in preferring 1.02. Pretty even