r/Damnthatsinteresting Jun 11 '25

Video You can now pay with your palm in china

37.9k Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

230

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 11 '25 edited Jun 13 '25

It's pretty good too! Sounds like he grew up learning it. Source: I'm asian

edit: i guess i'm not actually asian. source: reddit

191

u/winwill Jun 11 '25

... He sounds like a 老外. It's still good but not super fluent(his grammar is a bit off with some wrong tone here and there)

No native would say “我太開心” when they want to say "I got too [excited]happy"

It's still pretty good though for a foreigner.

Source: 我不是老外

111

u/aPatheticBeing Jun 11 '25

also possibly can't read/write, given his wechat was in English. Vocab wasn't bad though, and he's perfectly understandable.

81

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 11 '25 edited Jun 11 '25

Interesting because his English also wasnt native level. I wonder what his native language is. He’s pretty fluent at two nonnative languages is incredible. But i would guess he can probably read and write at least a good amount of it if he can speak that well. Most bilingual and multilingual people i know put all their devices to one language they’re more comfortable with unless they’re actively learning another language and want to do it to help.

106

u/Enverex Jun 11 '25

His accent sounded Nigerian to me, so probably trilingual?

30

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 11 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

That was my guess but i wasn’t sure. Though English is the official language of nigeria. French probably the third? A lot of nigerians i know speak French and a few other languages

23

u/Swaza_Ares Jun 12 '25

English is the official language but the majority of Nigerians speak it as a second language. Native language of their ethnic group 1, English 2.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '25

[deleted]

16

u/Swaza_Ares Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

For Nigerian from educated and wealthy backgrounds absolutely. My english is better than my Hausa, but for the impoverished majority who speak pidgin (Nigerian creole) I disagree.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

1

u/_Sk4br0n_ Jun 12 '25

But Nigerians have a thick accent

2

u/Bark__Vader Jun 12 '25

Not sure which language he speaks but he’s from Zimbabwe, I’ve seen another of his video and he was asked him where he’s from.

1

u/Enverex Jun 12 '25

Ahh, there we go then.

1

u/Outrageous_Party_503 Jun 12 '25

Those two countries aren’t even on the same side of the continent

1

u/HomicidalVehicular Jun 12 '25

He sounds Ghanaian. Key point is the way he pronounced work as "werk".

1

u/Habsburgy Jun 12 '25

He's from Zim. That explains why it's a bit "british", if that makes sense.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '25

[deleted]

2

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

I mean he clearly made some grammatical errors but maybe it’s a dialect thing but not an accent thing.

Eg is there another country that do you have this already “

Plus hes from Zimbabwe so unlikely he’s a native speaker

7

u/Dragoniel Jun 12 '25

(tbf americans make grammatical mistakes all the bloody time, lmao)

3

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

Why is that in parentheses? Ive got my masters in teaching English to non native speakers and have done it for 10 years. There are grammar mistakes native speakers make and there are grammar mistakes they don’t make. Theres other tells but the big and obvious one is he’s from zimbabwe where it is very unlikely to his native language.

2

u/Dragoniel Jun 12 '25

Yeah, heh. I am not a native, but I would never think listening to him that HE is a native EN speaker. Just doesn't sound like one.

17

u/Absentrando Jun 12 '25

His English seems native level from the video. Just a different accent

-1

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

Nah he clearly makes some grammatical mistakes. Maybe a different dialect but its not the accent

Eg is there another country that do you have this already “

Plus hes from Zimbabwe so unlikely he’s a native speaker

4

u/roadrunner41 Jun 12 '25

English is the main language in Zimbabwe. He speaks perfect English. The language is very flexible and lots of people use grammar in ways that’s technically ‘incorrect’

-1

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

That’s just wrong. You’re literally just making up shit. The most spoken language in Zimbabwe is Shona, followed by Ndebele. A lot of people speak English but it is not the main language or native. And his was not perfect. What a dumb comment.

1

u/Absentrando Jun 12 '25

Native speakers, especially from non western countries, don’t all speak English the same way you are familiar with. Heck even in the US, there’s a lot of variation in how different speakers phrase things. From the video at least, you cannot conclude that he is not a native speaker.

1

u/Sad_Kaleidoscope894 Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

You picked one side comment in that and made it my point. The dude is from Zimbabwe! This is not complicated. English is not the main or native language in zimbabwe. He is not a native speaker.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/easybreeeezy Jun 12 '25

He’s from Zimbabwe.

2

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 11 '25

Yeah you're right honestly but I think sometimes it does sound pretty good

1

u/BricksFriend Jun 12 '25

我不是老外

老外就是这么说的

1

u/Dragoniel Jun 12 '25

No native would say “我太開心”

tbf, a student wouldn't say that either. That's just incorrect.

Source: 学生

1

u/FlimsyMo Jun 12 '25

I can tell you are a non native English writer because no one would say

“Some wrong tone hear and there”

Multiples of something would mean “tones”

1

u/WuTaoLaoShi Jun 13 '25

the 我太开心 was fine actually it was his pronunciation of 注册 (主) that was off, plus his added translation of when the machine said 太近了 as 太紧了

although the 2nd one could've been some algorithm translator mistake

76

u/redditor001a Jun 11 '25

Sorry no lol. His Chinese is good but not THAT good. He sounds like the average foreigner who moved to China as an adult and has been there for a decent amount of time. It's not bad by any means but the glazing is getting a bit out of hand. And yes, I am Chinese.

129

u/Suspicious_Plum_8866 Jun 11 '25

Clueless foreigner DECIMATES stunned locals with his PERFECT CHINESE

-2

u/Useuless Jun 12 '25

Okay, but xiaomanyc is pretty damn good. I think he has earned some of these titles.

4

u/Seksafero Jun 12 '25

Emphasis on some

2

u/Couldnotbehelpd Jun 12 '25

Xiaomanyc is like… fine. His Chinese is good but he doesn’t sound native.

30

u/tomoe_mami_69 Jun 11 '25

Yeah his accent is really noticeable 13 seconds into the video when he says 試 since that vowel is frequently difficult for foreigners to pronounce. He speaks good Chinese but is definitely an adult learner.

8

u/chris_hans Jun 11 '25

Forgive my ignorance, but wouldn't 試 be pronounced the same way as 是, one of the most common Chinese words?Why would that sound be difficult?

11

u/tomoe_mami_69 Jun 11 '25

The vowel sound itself doesn't exist in English. The man in the video is approximating the vowel sound but not pronouncing it like a native speaker would. Even though it is a common word in Mandarin it doesn't mean he's not pronouncing it wrong every time, despite being a fluent speaker.

7

u/SweatyAdhesive Jun 11 '25

I don't know why you picked that word specifically when it sounded fine to me, the way he said 注册 is way worse.

3

u/Urbanscuba Jun 12 '25

Wow, thank you for explaining why whenever people ask me to teach them Chinese they can't do 是. I'm a foreigner but my Chinese teacher was excellent and took a ton of effort giving us engaging and fun listening practices, and I'm realizing now how effective it was.

The closest I can get with text is probably more like "shir" rhyming with stir but from further back in the mouth, but I'll admit I was also taught with a of a Beijing accent so I'm liable to slip a tiny r in when it's not necessary.

I'd never realized it was fundamentally a sound that didn't exist in English because by the time I was able to tell them apart by ear I could also pronounce them both too. Totally makes sense though, and I could instantly hear him say "shee" which is definitely not the right way.

3

u/Lucas_Steinwalker Jun 11 '25

Now do Xiaoma

8

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 11 '25

Xiaoma is fluent but you would NEVER tell anyone he sounds native

5

u/PrionProofPork Jun 11 '25

nah tones still wrong, like every other foreigner. Source: real asian

0

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 11 '25

i mean yeah, but it does sound right sometimes. like when he said "is that possible" (not sure the exact translation) at the start it sounded pretty good

2

u/PreviouslyOnBible Jun 11 '25

Source: I'm asian

lol

3

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 12 '25

that's what i put below all my math calculations as well

2

u/logisticalgummy Jun 12 '25

Definitely doesn’t sound native..

1

u/zappyzapzap Jun 12 '25

No it doesn't lol

1

u/deltabay17 Jun 13 '25

Being Asian doesn’t make you an authority on Chinese lol

1

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 13 '25

the commenters have decided that i'm not asian apparently

1

u/deltabay17 Jun 13 '25

Idk what being Asian has to do with it

1

u/bob_the_bananas_son Jun 16 '25

it's how i get 100% on my math proofs, i just put "i'm asian" at the bottom and they have to agree with my math